When your loved one’s murder becomes a documentary: who gets to tell their story?

For viewers, a true-crime series has a beginning and an ending. For the people who loved the person at its centre, the story continues long after the credits. What happens when a private loss becomes something strangers watch and discuss?

By

Someone sends you a trailer. There is a familiar photograph, your loved one’s name and a story you know more intimately than you ever wanted to.

For the audience, this may be a new discovery. For you, it is the return of something that has never really gone away.

A documentary can offer families an opportunity to speak, challenge an account or bring attention to failures they want addressed. It can also create difficult questions about what to share, how much to watch and how to live with other people’s interest afterwards.

At the centre is someone whose life was much larger than the circumstances of their death.

When telling the story has a purpose

For Mina Smallman, participating in the BBC documentary Two Daughters offered a way to tell her family’s story following the murders of her daughters, Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman, in 2020.

Released in 2022, the film followed Mina and her husband Chris through the court proceedings and explored their concerns about the police response and the treatment of their daughters. It also included memories from people who knew them: Bibaa was a social worker; Nicole was a photographer. Their lives, relationships and personalities belonged within the account.

That example shows one reason a family might choose to participate. Speaking publicly can serve a purpose beyond recounting a crime.

But participation is a personal decision. Someone may want their relative remembered without wanting to discuss the investigation on camera. Another family member may feel strongly that speaking is important. There need not be one response shared by everyone who is grieving.

Being informed matters

Much of the difficulty can concern how the story reaches the screen. Has the family been approached thoughtfully? Do they understand the programme’s focus? Have they had time to consider what taking part would involve?

For programmes covered by its Broadcasting Code, Ofcom says broadcasters should try to reduce potential distress when revisiting traumatic events, including crime, unless there is justification for doing otherwise. So far as reasonably practicable, surviving victims or immediate families should be informed about the plans and intended broadcast, even when material is already public and being informed does not automatically give a family editorial control.

For someone considering an interview, practical questions may help: Who else will contribute? How will photographs or recordings be used? What support is available? Who can they contact afterwards?

The Association of True Crime Producers’ guidelines address these concerns, including transparency, contributor welfare, transmission dates and discussing advance viewing where appropriate.

When the audience arrives

Once a programme is released, the attention may extend far beyond the film. Friends might send reviews without asking. A colleague may want to discuss a scene. Online viewers may speculate about decisions, relationships or details that occupy only a few minutes of screen time.

Even a well-intentioned message can arrive on a day when someone has little capacity to respond. You can appreciate that people care while asking them to stop forwarding coverage.

It may help to choose one trusted person to pass on anything genuinely important, leaving you free to avoid the wider discussion. You can also decide whether you want to watch, watch with support or leave the programme alone.

You don’t have to become the person who answers every question about it. Nor must you correct every stranger’s interpretation to demonstrate loyalty to someone you loved.

Keep room for memories beyond the crime

A documentary necessarily selects. It cannot contain every friendship, habit, family disagreement or afternoon that made a person familiar.

That limitation can feel particularly painful when the same photograph appears repeatedly, until it seems to stand for an entire life.

Away from public attention, you might want space for other memories: the meal they always requested, their terrible directions, the song they insisted on playing. Share those stories with people who knew them, if and when you want to.

There is no obligation to make another public tribute or supply a more complete account. Some memories can remain yours.

For friends supporting a bereaved family, a useful starting point is to ask how they feel about the programme before offering an opinion. Remembering the person’s life may be more welcome than discussing the production.

A film will eventually end. The family’s relationship with the person who died continues, shaped by far more than the story an audience has been shown.