Signs you’re suffering from a social uncertainty loop – and practical ways to break the cycle

Pics: Getty Images

 If a simple full stop at the end of the message sends you into a spiral, and not getting a response can feel worse than rejection you might be suffering from social uncertainty and it’s more common than you think.

A recent study revealed that social uncertainty caused a stronger association with anxiety disorder symptoms than negative responses.  

Therapist, Natalie Buchwald, and managing director of Manhattan Mental Health Counseling, Steven Buchwald, reveal signs you might be suffering from social uncertainty, and more importantly, how to deal with it. 

You look for hidden meanings

There’s a lot of room for interpretation when it comes to messages compared to a real life conversation, as the tone can be entirely changed with the use of an emoji. Without the social cues we use to understand the other person, like their voice, facial expression, and body language, there isn’t enough information to answer the questions you’re asking yourself. 

Your brain starts to fill the gaps, searching for hidden meanings; but the more you reread it, the more meanings you think you’re finding, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you’re any closer to the truth.

You notice every detail in messaging habits

They usually reply within an hour but today it took three, or they usually send multiple messages but today they sent one. Perhaps their messages are usually full of emojis but today was emoji-free – it can be easy to notice, and you can find yourself comparing this message with every conversation you’ve ever had with them. 

A slight change in messaging habits doesn’t always have something to do with you; they might just be busy, tired, or distracted, and not even noticed that they didn’t use an emoji. 

You turn ‘I don’t know’ into ‘I’ve done something wrong’

A 2025 study found that negative interpretations of ambiguous social situations explained the relationship between uncertainty and social anxiety. When a situation is unclear, like getting a message you think is ‘unusual’, the tendency to interpret the uncertainty negatively can increase. In other words, thinking “I don’t know what could be wrong” can very quickly turn into “I have definitely done something wrong”. 

Uncertainty and rejection aren’t the same thing, and not getting a reply doesn’t mean you’ve done something wrong; the information you’ve received from not getting an immediate reply isn’t that something isn’t right, it just means they haven’t replied yet. 

You ask someone else to decode the message

 When you can’t work out the ‘hidden meanings’ you’ve been searching for, it can be tempting to send a screenshot to someone else and ask if they think it sounds off. This might provide some immediate relief but if you find yourself constantly needing someone else to tell you that everything is fine, it can keep your attention locked onto the uncertainty. 

A second opinion can be very helpful if you really can’t work out what they mean, but there’s a difference between asking someone else because you’re unsure and repeatedly looking for reassurance because you can’t stand not knowing. 

You can’t leave it alone

 Perhaps the biggest sign that you have a problem with social uncertainty is that you just can’t leave it alone, and how long you continue to think about the situation. You put your phone down, and immediately pick it up again, reread the message, put your phone down, pick it up… and the cycle continues for hours. 

The problem isn’t necessarily that you’re still thinking about it, it’s that you’re not able to disengage from it. Your attention becomes so fixed on trying to get answers to the questions you’ve created that you get stuck in the loop, hoping you’ll get new information that you missed the first time. 

It’s not just messages from your friends…

When you’re communicating with someone whose tone you’re not totally familiar with, work emails can be even harder to interpret than messages from your friends. This can be particularly noticeable when you get an email from a boss, as you could already be sensitive to how they communicate. There have even been thousands of TikToks about the anxiety you can feel when your boss responds with a thumbs up rather than a ‘thank you’, showing how much meaning we attach so something as small as an emoji.

The use of a smiley face, or even just an exclamation mark, can make an email feel warmer, but the absence of one can make you feel like they’re unhappy with you or that you have done something wrong. Pay attention to the email itself, rather than trying to treat punctuation and formatting as a hidden emotional message. 

So, how do you best deal with social uncertainty?

Ask yourself what you actually know. Don’t try to work out what the message means, what your friend thinks it means, or the worries you have about the meaning, just think about the facts. Sometimes, the facts are simply that they haven’t replied yet, their message was short, and they didn’t end it with an x; everything else is just how you’re interpreting it. 

Give yourself an ‘understanding deadline’. When you’re in a social uncertainty spiral, it can be difficult to suddenly stop thinking about it, so instead of trying to solve the ambiguous situation for days, give yourself a deadline. Allowing yourself an hour to think about the message creates a boundary around the uncertainty rather than letting it take over your whole day. 

 Stop letting your phone be the place where you search for reassurance. If you’re nervous about someone’s response (or lack of response), constantly checking your notifications, whether or not they’ve been online, or viewed your Instagram story since you sent your last message can make you feel like you’re getting answers, but instead, you’re simply creating more thing to interpret. Put your phone out of reach and do something else that demands your full attention, rather than trying to use every notification from other people as evidence about how this person feels. 

 Pay attention to what you do when you feel uncertain. Do you constantly reread the messages or send more messages to see if you get a response? Do you mentally replay the conversation? Not everyone responds the same way to not knowing, and when you can recognise your pattern, you have more of an opportunity to pause and think about it before automatically doing the things that keep you stuck in the loop. 

 Let some questions remain unanswered. Not every social situation will come with a complete explanation, and trying to understand every detail can be exhausting. Someone might reply in a slightly different way, and the conversation could feel unusual, but there might not be a specific reason. Learning to tolerate that lack of closure and understanding can be much more useful than trying to create your own explanations. The healthiest option might not be total certainty, but being comfortable enough to carry on without it.