It’s rightly seen as a strength — but if you’re in a narcissistic relationship, empathy can be exactly what keeps you from leaving.

We’ve heard more and more about empathy in recent years. It’s been rebranded — once simply part of getting along with other people, it’s now framed as a kind of superpower, the key to deeper connection and understanding. But it turns out that too much of a good thing can come at a cost — especially if there’s a narcissist involved.

“You can’t get into a relationship with a narcissist if you’re not empathetic,” says the Divorce Coach, Sara Davison. After years of working with people navigating breakups, divorce and toxic relationships, she’s seen the same pattern repeat. “The people who get pulled in aren’t weak,” she says. “They’re usually the ones who care the most.”

It’s a difficult idea to sit with. Empathy is supposed to help us — to protect us in relationships, not make us more vulnerable. But in narcissistic dynamics, it can be exactly what keeps someone in place.

Empathy makes you look for reasons — not red flags

“Highly empathetic people don’t just react to behaviour,” Davison explains. “They try to understand it. So instead of thinking, ‘That’s not okay,’ they’re thinking, ‘What’s happened to make them act like that?’”

That instinct — to look beneath the surface — can be powerful. It creates patience, compassion, and a willingness to see the bigger picture. But in the context of narcissistic behaviour, it can also blur important lines.

“You see the wound behind the behaviour,” she says. “And when you do that, you’re more likely to stay and try to fix it.”

Instead of recognising a boundary has been crossed, the focus shifts to explanation. The behaviour becomes something to interpret, rather than something to act on.

Empathy makes the beginning feel more real

“Narcissistic personalities are very good at working people out,” Davison says. “They’ll find out what matters to you, what you’re scared of, what you need — and then they reflect that back.”

To an empathetic person, that can feel like a genuine connection. Like being seen, understood, chosen. And that early version of the relationship carries weight.

When things begin to change — when warmth gives way to criticism, distance or control — it doesn’t immediately register as a warning sign. “You’re thinking, ‘This isn’t who they really are,’” she explains. “Because you’ve seen a different version of them.”

That belief can keep people invested far longer than they might otherwise be.

Familiar patterns can make it harder to spot

For some, there’s also a sense of familiarity that’s difficult to recognise in the moment. “If you’ve grown up around unpredictability, or you’ve had to manage other people’s emotions from quite a young age, that can feel normal,” Davison says. “Not comfortable — but normal.”

That means the emotional inconsistency often seen in narcissistic relationships doesn’t always stand out straight away. “You’re not thinking, ‘This is wrong for me,’” she says. “You’re thinking, ‘How do I make this work?’”

And that mindset — problem-solving, adapting, accommodating — can keep people engaged even as the dynamic shifts.

Self-doubt doesn’t appear all at once — it builds

The change in the relationship is rarely dramatic. More often, it shows up in smaller, disorienting moments. “You start second-guessing yourself,” Davison says. “You’re thinking, ‘Did I get that wrong? Am I overreacting?’”

In narcissistic relationships, that doubt is often reinforced through gaslighting. “They’ll challenge your version of events,” she explains. “Or make you feel like you’re the problem.”

Over time, that repeated questioning begins to take hold. “That’s how self-doubt creeps in,” she says. “And once that’s there, everything becomes harder.” She describes instinct as something people slowly learn to override. “Your instinct is like a burglar alarm,” she says. “It goes off when something’s not right. But people ignore it.”

At first, it’s clear — a feeling you can’t quite shake. But if it’s repeatedly dismissed, minimised or turned back on you, it starts to fade. “And when you stop listening to it,” she says, “you lose your reference point.”

Losing trust in yourself can keep you stuck

Without that internal certainty, the balance of the relationship begins to shift. “People think being stuck means you don’t know something’s wrong,” Davison says. “But most people do know. They just don’t trust themselves enough to act on it.”

That loss of trust doesn’t stay contained. “You hesitate more. You question more. You look outside yourself for answers instead of within,” she explains. And in a narcissistic dynamic, that often deepens reliance on the other person — the very person who is destabilising you.

There’s a very human reason people stay

Beyond psychology, there’s something more fundamental at play. “We all have a fundamental need for love and connection,” Davison says. “And one of the biggest fears people have is that they’re going to end up on their own.”

That fear can be especially strong in relationships that began intensely. “When someone has made you feel that seen, that wanted, it’s very hard to let go of,” she says.

Leaving, then, isn’t just about walking away from what the relationship has become. It’s also about letting go of what it once felt like — and what it promised to be.

It’s not weakness — it’s strength in the wrong direction

What Davison sees again and again is that the people who struggle to leave aren’t lacking strength. If anything, they’ve been using it constantly — trying to hold things together, trying to understand, trying to make it work.

“The issue isn’t that they’re weak,” she says. “It’s that they’re strong in the wrong direction.”

The work isn’t about becoming less empathetic. It’s about recognising when that empathy is being used against you.

“Empathy on its own isn’t enough,” she says. “You need boundaries alongside it.” That shift can feel unfamiliar at first — especially for people used to prioritising others. But it starts simply. “Listening to yourself again,” she says. “Taking your own feelings seriously.”

Because one of the things narcissistic relationships erode most effectively is self-trust. “And once you rebuild that,” she says, “everything else becomes a lot clearer.”

Images: Shutterstock